3 comments so far
This reminds me of the old salt and pepper shakers of “mammies” that are so popular for collection. The difference is, and unfortunately, it depicts a historical time that we (I am a black woman with a range of backgrounds) would like to forget. It’s offensive but I also have seen black collectors save and find such things because it marks a moment in time in our history.
However, this wine holder is simply offensive. With no merit except the stereotype it conjures up. Not saying one is worst than the other, but I have no period in history or attachment I feel I need to join with this figure.
This is one of those examples of pure, unadulterated racism. No saving graces or gray areas on this one.
And yet, you can expect a monsoon of deniers and defenders going ape spaz in the defense of this sort of thing.
I’m not really sure entirely where this kind of knee jerk hostile reaction comes from, but it’s dependable as mosquitoes and sucking blood.
If Natives can’t be insulted by stuff like this, what can they be insulted by?
While the McDonald’s toy didn’t bother me (because it was based on a film and wasn’t doing anything derogatory) this wine bottle holder does bother me because it’s featuring a Native American in a negative posture.

[...] last wrote about this wine holder back in July and, after a flurry of hurt feelings and even some productive discussions about race, assumed that [...]